Best Propane Tank for Grill (Top 10 Reviews, Brands Compare & Buying Guide 2021)

Best Propane Tank for Grill (Top 10 Reviews, Brands Compare & Buying Guide 2021)
Furniturebyte is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page.

The pungent smell of grill tickling your nostrils might be one of the most mouthwatering moments of your life. Thinking about it triggers visions inside my head of grilling barbeques in my backyard with my friends and family. 

Just like fashion trends, food trends also change, but BBQ is something that will forever remain iconic.

And for grilling something, nothing can be better than propane. A propane grill achieves full temperature under 15 minutes on average. It also offers you a variety of methods for cooking almost anything. No matter your cooking choices, indirect heat or multi-zone cooking, propane allows you to cook however you want, whenever you want.

Now a few questions may linger inside your head. Like what propane tank will be the best for me? How big a tank should be? How do I buy the best tank? 

Well, to get all your questions answered, keep reading as we dive deep into the reviews of my hand-selected best propane tank for grill and talk about how they work.

What size should a propane tank be?

Propane Tank Sizes

Before deciding what size your propane tank should be, you have to know that there are many sizes, and each serves a different purpose. 

  • 20 Pound Propane Cylinder: Suitable for minimal use like grilling or other small residential needs such as a fireplace. But these tanks do not give you the privilege to heat homes or anything that needs energy in a large amount. It is portable.
  • 100 Pound Tanks: These tanks are a great choice if you have smaller heating devices or smaller appliances that need propane. You can also rely on these tanks to power up your gas cooking ranges. It is relatively portable as they tend to be heavy.
  • 420 Pounds (100 Gallons) Tanks: Very large to use for many different commercial purposes. You can also use them for residential uses as well. They will work well enough to heat homes and swimming pools as well. They also can be used as power emergency generators.
  • 500 Gallons Tanks: The widely used size of propane tanks for many residential uses. You can cook, grill, heat homes, swimming pools, and much more. The main benefit of these tanks is that you can use them for longer periods without getting them refilled every once in a while.
  • 1000 Gallon Tanks: They serve the same purpose as the 500-gallon tanks, but they are twice as big and last longer. However, I will not recommend you buy it unless you have a very big house like at least 4500 sq. Ft.

10 Best Propane Tank for Grill Reviews 2021

Best Small Propane Tanks for a Grill : Worthington 303955 Steel Propane Cylinder

Best Small Propane Tanks for a Grill : Worthington 303955 Steel Propane Cylinder

The manufacturer has won the hearts of many and rewards for their safety practices and regulations. This tank comes in many sizes, starting from 4.25-100 pounds.

Durable Stainless Steel: The 20 pounds tank is made out of durable stainless steel and will last very long. Resistant to rust, the tank has durabond powder coat finish. The interior is very dry and clean.

Lightweight: The lightweight technology of this tank makes it very portable. You can move it from here to there by using the comfortable hand-holder in the collar. It is one of the best small propane tanks for a grill.

Versatile: The tank works perfectly fine both in summer and winter. There is no scale presence inside the tank, and it will work with every gas grill out there. You would be surprised to know that the tank has ISO 9002 certificate for quality.

Advantages & Disadvantages: There is no chance of internal damage. For safety, the tank comes with an overflow prevention valve. The outer layer is resistant to rust and damage. Very easy to lift and car. In contrast, it doesn’t come with a hose or valve.

Best 5 lb Propane tank for grill: Flame King YSN5LB

Best 5 lb Propane tank for grill: Flame King YSN5LB

If you have lived in the USA, you’d probably know that Flame King is one of the leading brands of kitchen appliances. They always take safety measures when it comes to equipment like a propane tank. It is one of the most used personalized tanks for grilling. This small propane tank for grills will save you money and allow adjusting in tiny spaces.

Construction: Made out of the world’s top-class welded steel to make sure that it is resistant to damage. There is also powder-coated all over the body to make it long-lasting for all the years that are to come.

Certified: The tank has passed tests starting from hydrostatic to X-ray. In addition, there are DOT and TC certifications of this product that translates into the Department of Transportation and Transport Canada.

Safe and Secure: Pre-purged and ready to be filled with LP gas and ensure that the grill lovers are safe. For secure use, the tank is equipped with OPD, which means Overfilling Prevention Device. It will help you to know about the volume of propane inside.

Advantages & Disadvantages: This can be used with grills, heaters, trailers, RVs, and many more. It is available in different capacities. It comes pre-purged and ensures all the mandatory safety measures. But I think it is a bit pricey tank.

Best 11 lb Propane Tank For Grill: Manchester Tank & Equip 10393.1

Best 11 lb Propane Tank For Grill: Manchester Tank & Equip 10393.1

Sometimes we need small propane tanks for grills. Like if you are camping at a mountain and have plans for a grill party, you should take a small and portable tank that would be easy to carry like this one.

Design: I bet that you will be stunned by its vertical color and design. As the colonial white powder coats it, the design gives a sense of simplicity, and the coat also prevents the tank from rusting and other damages like corrosion.

Safest: I think you will not have to worry about any safety issues with this Manchester tank. Equipped with a QCC1 Acme Valve keeps the tank full at the exact volume of gas along with the trending OPD. In addition, the tank is air tested (dry pneumatic) three times to avoid any type of issues.

OTG Tank: After using this propane tank from Manchester, you will realize that the company matched everything with DOT rules. You can also consider this tank as an on-the-go tank for its portability. There is a built-in collar for carrying it on the collar.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Meets every DOT requirement and has been air tested at least three times. You will find an active collar at the handle EZ collar. A low-profile propane tank with low maintenance. Sadly, Won’t work with home heaters.

Best 20 lb Propane Tank For Grill: Flame King YSN40HOGa Horizontal & Vertical Propane Cylinder

Best 20 lb Propane Tank For Grill: Flame King YSN40HOGa Horizontal & Vertical Propane Cylinder

For excess uses, you will need a bigger propane tank. So, to solve your top necessities, Flame King has brought you a propane tank of 40 pounds whether you need a grill, power up something, or cook. Your problems will be solved.

Hassle-Free Movement: There are two wheels aligned at the bottom of the tank that allows you to move the tank from here and there without any difficulty. The tank is really one of its kind, and very hard to find another one like this. The wheels are simply a life-saver.

Huge Volume of Gas: The tank holds about 9 gallons of propane so it will be a while before you need the tank to be refilled. And the tank comes pre-purged so that you don’t have to purge after you get them. You can fill the tank immediately.

Runs on Easily: This tank works with liquid propane as well as vapor propane. So, it really runs on easily. The liquid gas flows through the hose and then inside the low-pressure adapter. And the vaporized propane works with the pressure valve installed inside the hose. 

Advantages & Disadvantages: Works in both horizontal and vertical form. The tank comes with a Handle-EZ collar design. Very innovative design with wheels and constructed with rugged steel. But, while using it, I found it hard to read how much propane is left with the gauge.

Best 20 lb Propane Tanks for Barbecue: Worthington 281149 1-Gallon Steel Propane Cylinder

Best 20 lb Propane Tanks for Barbecue: Worthington 281149 1-Gallon Steel Propane Cylinder

I already discussed a product from this manufacturer, but I couldn’t resist adding this one to my list. The all-in-one 20-pound propane cylinder.

Lightweight: The lightweight innovation of this tank makes it truly versatile. You can move it from here to thereby utilize the agreeable hand-holder in the collar. It is one of the minuscule propane tanks for barbecue. 

Adaptable: The tank works entirely fine both in summer and winter. There is no scale presence inside the tank and will work with each gas barbecue. You would be astonished to realize that the tank has ISO 9002 endorsement for quality.

Solid Stainless Steel: The 20-pound Propane cylinder is made out of tempered steel that is strong and will keep going extremely long. Impervious to rust, the tank has a dura bond powder coat finish. The inside is extremely dry and clean.

Advantages & Disadvantages: The cylinders are manufactured to TC and DOT specifications and engineered for supreme quality and lightweight. Comfortable hand-hold to lift the cylinder easily—dura bond coating powder to prevent rust. But, the price of this tank fluctuates a lot.

YSN Equip 10504 Grill 20 lb Propane Tank

YSN Equip 10504 Grill 20 lb Propane Tank

The next product I will talk about will be very convenient for long-time campers, vanlifers, and backyard grillers. The tank from YSN will be very helpful to you as it is the best propane tank.

Gray Powder Coated: Powder coating gives the tank many distinct superiorities to galvanizing. The gray powder adds extra durability to the strength of this cylinder and even protects it from UV rays. 

Scalloped Foot Ring: The scalloped foot ring at the bottom of this cylinder helps it to balance itself and standstill. Even with accidental trips, the scalloped foot ring will protect it from falling.

Stop Fill Valve: The tank is DOT certified and comes with a stop fill valve. This valve automatically shuts off the filling process and restrains from overfilling. It will also tell you if the tank is low on propane.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Holds about 4.7 gallons of propane. Pre-purged to make the filling very easy. Equipped with overfill protection device and resistant to rust—no hose to connect. You have to buy it separately.

Best Cheap Propane Cylinders for the grill: Worthington Cylinders 334669 Cylinder Propane

Best Cheap Propane Cylinders for the grill: Worthington Cylinders 334669 Cylinder Propane

I mean, what can I say? Can you blame me for adding the Worthington tanks over and over again simply because they are amazing? I am sure that none of the tanks will disappoint you.

Versatile: The tank works totally fine both in summer and winter. You would be astounded to understand that the tank has ISO 9002 underwriting for quality. There is no scale presence inside the tank, and it will work with each gas grills out there.

Strong Stainless Steel: The 20 pounds tank is made out of tempered steel that is solid and will continue to go very long. Impenetrable to rust, the tank has dura bond powder coat finish. Within is very dry and clean.

Lightweight: The lightweight development of this tank makes it really adaptable. You can move it from here to there by using the pleasant hand-holder in the collar. It is one of the best cheap propane cylinders for the grill.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Very rugged and versatile. Designed with safety for strength. The tank works very well from the residential grill to industrial and commercial premises. Sadly, it takes a while to fill the gas.

Best Propane tank for Grill and BBQ: Varies New 20 lb. Steel Propane/LP Cylinder with OPD Valve

Best Propane tank for Grill and BBQ: Varies New 20 lb. Steel Propane/LP Cylinder with OPD Valve

Another portable, durable, and refillable best propane tank for grill and BBQ. Both Dot and TC approved, the cylinder is everything you want to have at home. It is the best price 20 lb propane tank at the current time with all its features. 

Colossal Volume of Gas: The tank holds around 9 gallons of propane, so it will be some time before you need the tank to be topped off. What’s more, the tank comes pre-cleaned so you don’t need to cleanse after you get them. Instead, you can fill the tank right away. 

Runs on Easily: This tank works with fluid propane just as fume propane. Along these lines, it truly runs on without any problem. The fluid gas moves through the hose and afterward inside the low-pressure connector. What’s more, the disintegrated propane works with the strain valve introduced inside the hose.

Easy Movement: There are two wheels adjusted at the lower part of the tank that permits you to move the tank from to a great extent with no trouble. The tank is truly one of its sorts and exceptionally difficult to come by another like this. The wheels are essentially a lifeline.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Powder coated and shot-blasted to add durability. It comes with carry handles. You can use it for patio heaters, and the construction is very solid. Again, another tank that does not come with a gauge.

Best 11-pound Flame King Propane Tank + OPD valve: Flame King YSN11SQT 11 Pound Propane Tank with Type 1 OPD Valve

Best 11-pound Flame King Propane Tank + OPD valve: Flame King YSN11SQT 11 Pound Propane Tank with Type 1 OPD Valve

Small space? No problem, I solve it with the 11-pound Flame King Propane Tank + OPD valve. Honestly, it is so small so that you can fit it in any corner of your house, and nobody would even notice. 

Type-1 OPD Valve: The OPD stands for overfill protection device that helps you not to overfill the tank and provide safety measures. There is also an accurate gauge that allows you to see how much gas is left so that you can fill it before the gas runs out. 

Exterior Protection: Constructed with high-grade, rugged, and stainless steel protects the tank from outer damage. Also, the dura bond powder helps to resist stain, rust, and corrosion.

Tests Approved: The tank has gone through hydrostatic tests and X-ray to ensure safety during the manufacturing process. In addition, the gas cylinder is DOT approved, and premium OPD valve assembly helps a lot.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Tanks arrive empty as it is dangerous to ship them fully. Powder coating inhibits rust—Hand-hold for easy movement and very low-profile. It cannot be used for heaters.

Flame King YSN301a Overflow Protection Device Valve

Flame King YSN301a Overflow Protection Device Valve

Flame King is the leader when it comes to propane storage problems and solutions. That is why customers have rated each of their tanks “the best”. The last one on our list is the best in our propane tank reviews.

Confirmed: The tank has breezed through assessment beginning from hydrostatic to X-beam. As a result, DOT and TC certificates of this item convert into the Department of Transportation and Transport Canada. 

Free from any danger: Pre-cleansed and fit to be loaded up with LP gas and ensures that the barbecue sweethearts are safe. For secure use, the tank is furnished with OPD, which means Overfilling Prevention Device. It will assist you with thinking about the volume of propane inside.

Development: Made out of the world’s top-class welded steel to ensure that it is impervious to harm. There is additionally powder-covered all around the body to make it durable for every one of the years to come.

Advantages & Disadvantages: Comes with a standard connection valve. The tank will work well with trailers and RVs and is attachable to heaters and other things. Very safe and secure. The filling time is long.

How to buy the best grill propane tank full package? 

When I tried to buy my first propane tank, a lot of things came to my mind. Starting from, “From where can I buy a propane tank?”, “Are all propane cylinders the same?” and many more? 

But the thing is, it is not that complicated as we make it seem. From my personal experience, I will tell you how easily you can buy a tank by looking at a few features. Also, for your ease you can follow my propane tank review to ease up the selection process.

  • Sizing: The size of a propane tank is an important factor to consider. Like if you have a tight space, you should not buy a big tank that will make your space even tighter. So, look around your house to figure out how big your tank should be.
  • Certifications: There are tanks that have U1A reports or National Board numbers that determine a tank’s specificity. Try looking for tanks that are DOT and TC certified as they ensure your safety.
  • Pricing: The propane cylinder price has a range starting from $400-$2000. The range is pretty big, so you should figure out your limit to avoid spending too much money. There are some cheap propane cylinders in the market that can fulfill your grilling demand, but sadly most of them are not so long lasting. 
  • Quality: This is very important as the quality of a propane tank is deeply related to your safety. If you buy tanks of cheap quality, your life will be in danger. So, try looking for tanks with heavy-duty, rugged steel. Also, look for tanks in lighter colors like white and silver to reflect sunlight and save it from harmful UV rays.

Manchester vs Worthington Propane Tanks

Feature Wise Comparison and contrast Between the Manchester and Worthington propane tank: 

Manchester vs Worthington Compare:

  •  Manchester Propane tanks are considered sources for portable heating, small commercial engines, temporary heating, drying cleaning, crop cleaning construction, and other valuable applications. In contrast, Worthington propane tanks can be used to power, grill, and heat for different types of applications.
  • The weight of the Manchester tank is comparatively lower than the weight of the Worthington propane tanks and is more durable.
  • The sizes of the Manchester propane tanks vary from 1 to 420 pounds, and the capacity of these tanks can range from 1 to 30000 gallons, according to the American Society of Mechanical Engineers. In contrast, the sizes of the Worthington propane tanks changes from 1 to 1000lb, and the capacity of these tanks is 1 to 23.6 gallons. ( The length can vary according to the manufacturer making time)
  • The Worthington propane tank is considered one of the giant tanks that can be carried manually, and it will last more than the other tanks, whereas the Manchester propane tank is not so big, but you can buy it at a low cost.
  • The Manchester propane tanks are better than Worthington propane tanks because they risk overfilling and leakage that can cause a fire. The Worthington propane tanks need to be pre purged if the leakage or filling of the propane occurs by the local propane supplier. So you need to pay extra money for the Worthington propane tanks.
  • There are some good sides to Manchester propane tanks, such as you can use this tank with the old heaters and stoves, whereas Worthington propane tanks have no features like this. 
  • One of the bad sides of the Manchester propane tanks is that all the adaptation and fixing needs to be done by a male fitting, whereas female fittings can quickly do the Worthington propane tanks.
  • Manchester Propane tanks were invented in 1945 in Los Angeles; the original building was situated in Manchester Avenue, whereas Worthington propane tanks were created in 1970 in Tennessee, which was known as the only two American producers of steel propane tanks or cylinders.

Manchester vs Worthington Contrast:

  • Both are coated with powdered paint for maximum rust protection, and you use them for a long time.
  • Both are made of steel, aluminum, and sometimes carbon. So there is less chance of getting a spark that can be considered as a more significant safety.
  • If you are a little careful, both can stop the overfilling of propane.
  •  Their bodies are solid and durable. So there will be no big problems if it gets scratched.
  • The most appreciable part of these two tanks is that the collar design feature has no sharp edges that make you hold it easily. In addition, their handles are made in such a way that makes them easy to carry.
  • These two tanks are easy to install.
  • Both of them are designed vertically.
  • Both of them are under the strict compliance of DOT
  • All sizes of propane tanks are available. 
  • Both were established in the USA.

Differences Between 5 lbs VS 20 lbs Propane tanks

One gallon or 1.2 gallons of propane can be kept in the 5lbs tanks, whereas in 20 lbs propane tanks, 4.5 gallons of propane can be carried.

  • 5lbs propane tanks are more advantageous compared to 20lbs because they are portable. So you can fill enough fuel for a multifold tank, and you can fill whenever you want as it will take little time to load and save money in the long days.
  • 5lbs propane tanks can be used for camping, tours, or emergency cases, whereas 20 lbs propane tanks can be used for mosquito magnets, barbecue grills, or cooking purposes, and you can use it as a small heater.

How to attach a mini propane tank to the grill?

Attaching a propane tank to the grill machine is one of the easiest things anyone can do with the proper follow-along guide. Unfortunately, most people are terrified to do so and seek professional help. But there is nothing to be worried about. Follow my guide, and you’ll be an expert in no time, and you’ll save money as well.

  1. Safety First: Before starting, make sure that every related item is in the right place. Ensure that the gas valve is closed and every knob of the griller is turned off. You should also be aware that both the griller and tank are away from flammable objects.
  2. Getting the Tank Ready: Now that everything is in the right place, you have to start connecting those two. Start by removing the seal from the tank and bring it closer to the griller. A little reminder that, once you have taken off the seal, you have to continue your work without any breaks until finished.
  3. Connection: Get the coupler of the grill and connect it to the valve of the tank. Make sure to tighten the valve with your hands. Do not use tools because you think it will be more effective, but instead, you may damage the tank.
  4. Gas Leak Test: Take soap water and place it over the connection between the tank and grill. After that, turn on the valve and wait for a few moments. If you notice that the soap water is bubbling, then your tank has a gas leak. Either because of poor connection of the hose or faulty cylinder. Rerun the test, and if the results are the same, return the tank.
  5. Start Grilling: Once the tank has passed the test, it’s time to throw a grill part with family and friends. But be sure to clean it regularly and take good care.

FAQs

Can I leave my propane tank on overnight?

Answer: No, you can’t. For your safety, you must turn off your tank after each use.

Will my tank explode in summer?

Answer: Yes, it can explode as the temperature in summer rises very quickly. The pressure inside the tank will rise, resulting in it exploding.

Can I store my tank in the garage?

Answer: Yes, only if your garage is outdoors and very well-ventilated.

Can I leave my gas grill outside in winter?

Answer: Yes, you can get without any problems if the temperature is not lower than –44-degree Fahrenheit.

Is it refilling or exchanging? Which one is cheaper?

Answer: refilling is the cheaper option as you can save $1.75 per gallon.

How long will a 5lb propane tank last?

Answer: Statistically, it will last between 18-20 hours.

How big is a grill propane tank?

Answer: The most widely used is the 20 lb. 

Conclusion

We have selected these top 10 best propane tanks for grill and enjoy with your family and friends. These are the best propane tank for grills under budget that customers always have been satisfied with.

We have tried our best to give you every specification of each of the tanks, along with the pros and cons. 

Finding a good propane tank might be challenging, but we hope we have made the job easy to incorporate all these exceptional tanks into the list. Let us know if you have a nice grill party with one of these.

See Also:

Tess Ferrell

It's really hard finding accurate information online when it comes to furnitures. Being frustrated, I decided to start a blog of my own to help out others like me. Hey, this is Tess Ferrel, I have more than 5 years of experience in home decorating and furniture industry. Hopefully, my experience, reviews, and guidelines will help you decorate your dream home. The goal is simple, to help you choose the best furniture without wasting your precious time, money, and effort.

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

Leave a reply

Furnishing Tips, Products Reviews & Guide
Logo